Thursday, November 30, 2023

Shortage of bottled water as an eye opener

It is not so long ago that most consumers hit a snag in their attempt to buy bottled water in shops ÔÇô atleast in the capital Gaborone. The shortage of bottled water has been solely blamed on the recent ban of importation of such by the government, precisely the Ministry of Trade and Investment. We have to state from the beginning that this move, by the government was long overdue and we 100 percent behind it.

While we wait for those who have the means to investigate this shortage ÔÇô to check whether it was due to lack of capacity by some local supplies (as some allege) or it was a clear sabotage by the big players in retail market, we cannot help but be grateful of this shortage because it was an eye opener in many ways.

It has helped us as a nation to see the need to support each other if we are to have citizens as active players in the economy. Gone are the days when Batswana were sidelined to the grand stands to become economic spectators in their own country.

With that noted, this leads us to out next point on the need to consider establishing cooperatives and turning them into a vehicle of citizen economic empowerment.

As we continue to ponder on job creation, income generation and citizen economic empowerment, it is becoming clear to us that we cannot achieve any of those without collaboration. This collaboration it seems it can come in the form of Co-operative societies, a concept that is not entirely new to us as a nation or player in the global village.

The idea of cooperatives of course originated in England in 1844. At that time, Rochdale Equitable Pioneers Society opened their store selling pure food at fair prices and honest weights and measures. The cooperative business revolution then saw a billion co-operators as members of 1.4 million cooperative societies across the world including as “deep” as Etsha 6, Botswana being part of the Rochdale Co-operative Theory. In fact, the last time we checked Etsha 6 Cooperative Society was one of the few surviving in our country.

In the early years of our independence, Co-operatives were seen as major players in development, loaded down with expectations, as well as government interference. As a result, many failed but that does not mean that they are not crucial in the advancement of our economy. As we all might be aware, the primary role of co-operatives is to meet their members’ needs. We therefore hope that a revival of Co-operatives, if successful, will aid the economic up-liftment of most of our people, atleast those who would be willing to be part of the movement.

In 2012, the government announced that it had reviewed the Co-operatives policy to allow more of our people to go into co- operative society business. We are not up to date on how far the review has gone in terms of “pushing” a lot of our people into that area.

We however suspect that a lot of Batswana, in the early 90s when most cooperative societies died, were dismissal of the concept. At the time, as we all know, most cooperative societies dramatically declined and later varnished into thin air. The death of the Co-operatives was, in our view, partially due to financial maladministration but also due to lack of proper guidance from the government, the ultimate parent.

It is very important to note that as we look into reviving the Co-operative sector we should not forget that capacity building, training and further education remain critical for development of the members of any societies that would be formed.  Strengthening networks between such Co-operatives is also crucial for the survival and the advancement of the domestic economy.

The social and economic benefits of the co-operatives can have a far reaching impact, but they need support from the development community to reach their potential. Actually for now they don’t need to reach full potential but rather revival at bare minimum.

The death of co-operatives has been recorded not just in Botswana but even elsewhere in the world. Reasons obviously differ but what is common is the fact that in recent in recent decades, the movement (co-operatives) have made a comeback.

This is surely because everyone has since realised that co-operatives can and do make major contributions to millennium development goals. Co-operatives come in all shapes and sizes and all sectors of the economy. This is why they can, if properly managed generate income for their members and also offer a range of benefits ÔÇô depending on why they are set up. In meeting their members needs co-operatives enhance incomes and secure livelihoods for their members and their communities by extension. As we have said before in this space, unemployment has a very strong link to high income inequality, exclusion, compromised quality of life and ultimately abject poverty. But like we have submitted before, as we hereby do, we should not be ashamed to recognise Co-operatives as crucial means for employment creation, poverty alleviation and economic growth for our people. The general meaning of cooperation is that isolated and powerless individuals can, by combining with one another, achieve advantages available to the rich and the powerful so that they may advance not only materially but also morally.

The #Bottomline is that much as we agree that Co-operatives cannot provide the whole answer to the economic injustice that our people are facing at the moment, they are certainly part of the answer. It is through cooperation that our people can start dreaming of becoming financial independent. It is through cooperation that even these so called big retail giants from across the border can see the need to appreciate Botswana goods and sell them in their shops.


Read this week's paper